Are Job Boards and Career Sites Dead?

Posted by Ira Kaufman on 11 Nov 2008 | Tagged as: Employer Branding, Recruitment Marketing, Social Network, job boards

Dan Schawbel wrote an interesting post on The Future of Online Recruitment.  He says

“The days of applying to jobs through corporate websites and job listing repositories will end. As the competition to get jobs increases year over year, the amount of resumes and cover letters HRM’s (Human Resource Management Systems) will hold will overflow and even crawlers won’t be able to save them. When you have a million resumes, and a crawler finds certain keywords, there will still be too many leftover, meaning they will have to interview a larger batch.  This costs HR more money and the applicant more time.”

Dan also suggests that Online Recruitment has 2 faces, 1:Many and 1:1.  1:many is when you respond to a posting through a corporate site, along with thousands of other hopeful candidates, and 1:1 is when hiring companies want to hire someone they know, trust and respect. Dan contends that 1:many fails because there is no human element involved.  He adds 

“the future of online recruitment is in 1:1 relationships, where you find people online, through social networks or blogs and form a relationship through mutual interest and a job opportunity is created.”

I agree that the days of job boards and resumes are numbered, but let’s look at the current online recruitment process. It has multiple stages; Attraction, Engagement and Submission. In the past each stage of this process was sterile and not responsive to the needs of the job seeker and not reflective of the targeted needs of the employer. There has been lots of wasted effort and money spent on poor matches.

This model began with the Company wanting to fill a job. The process was to post a job opening  and wait to get a resume and application.  There was little filtering and frustration on both sides of the process. 

Old Job Model

Old Job Model

Enter the age of social media and the process changes significantly.  The company begins with a need for attracting a passive or active job seeker to the company’s work environment and challenging positions. They use an Integrated Recruitment Marketing strategy which includes creating an employer brandadvertising as well as search engines, networking, blogs and social networks.  They direct the jobseeker to their career showcase which is an interactive online environment that encourages a conversation and builds a relationship.

Social Recruitment Model

Social Recruitment Model

I believe a morphed company career showcase that is not just a sterile career site is an important venue for engaging potential job seekers. Every transaction in the relationship building cannot be done 1:1 or offline. The online venue has to become a step in the relationship building and filtering process. Passive job seekers are looking for snapshots not sterile job boards to get a taste of a company’s values and their work environments.

Here are some similar posts on this subject …

  • Recruit Against the Tide
  • Recruitment Marketing: National Job Sites are not Cost Effective, Part 4
  • Facebook for Recruiting… What’s working
  • Employment Recruitment Marketing, Showcasing Your Company - Part 2
  • Building a Powerful Employer Brand in Recruitment Marketing
  • 4 Responses to “Are Job Boards and Career Sites Dead?”

    1. on 11 Nov 2008 at 9:00 am 1.Ben Waugh said …

      Where did you get your blog layout from? I’d like to get one like it for my blog.

    2. on 15 Nov 2008 at 2:27 pm 2.Peter said …

      About.com surveyed human resource professionals and recruiters about which of the top 10 job sites they found the best candidates on, survey results here:

      http://humanresources.about.com/gi/pages/poll.htm?poll_id=5763275227&linkback=http://humanresources.about.com/b/a/258241.htm

    3. on 18 Dec 2008 at 1:23 am 3.Diane Lee said …

      Unfortunately, employers don’t seem to have caught up with this new way of attracting and retaining staff. They are still stuck in the ‘old school’ paradigm which increasingly frustrates jobseekers who expect organisations to be more innovative in line with their brands. Thanks for your post - it is very enlightening.

    4. on 19 Feb 2009 at 11:33 am 4.Lindsay said …

      “the future of online recruitment is in 1:1 relationships, where you find people online, through social networks or blogs and form a relationship through mutual interest and a job opportunity is created.”

      A very interesting point, I don’t think we’re there quite yet though - there is still a lot of life left in 1:many recruitment!

    Trackback This Post | Subscribe to the comments through RSS Feed

    Leave a Reply